"War and Peace".. a review

....yep - done it!

..just in case you wondered why no posts, well with the start of the sailing season, combined with reading this - I've been busy! Always said I wanted to read it, I even made a random new year resolution that I would do it this year, and there you go...  finished it this morning...

So how do you review what most people consider to be one of the worlds greatest pieces of literature?? Shambolically... as you would expect on this blog... 

So in no particular order...

First, the book is  HUGE - I read it on Kindle, and even with the almost mythic battery length of the device I still had to recharge it twice during the period of reading just this one book...  basically the book took me from the beginning of April until now to finish...  6 or 7 weeks....

...it's a lot of time to invest in a book if you aren't going to enjoy it so..

Second - with a book that big make sure you get a good edition - there are lots and lots of cheap copies about, even free one's, but if you're going to invest that kind of time make sure you like the translation style of the book you choose...  I had a Kindle version from Amazon [clicky] that I chose to buy, rather than struggle with one of the free versions that I started with..

Third, it's a remarkably good story you'll be pleased to know, but it's interspersed with a lot of Mr Tolstoy's opinions and philosophy....  it's basically a book in 4 parts, but there's also a couple of large epilogues as well, and is about three main families plus a couple of lesser families, their lives, loves, intrigues, politics, feuds etc set against the Napoloenic Wars starting in 1805 and running up to Napoleon's invasion of Russia in 1812...

The main protagonist is a rather troubled chap called Pierre/Peter Bezukhov (I always had this mental image of him as Anthony Hopkins from the classic BBC version of the seventies - couldn't shake it) and his interaction with the other families - the Rostov's & the Bolkonsky's, and to a lesser extent the Kuragins and the Drubetskoys.

The Bezukhovs, are rich and slightly dysfunctional - the old Count, Pierre's father has fathered dozens of illegitimate sons and dies early in the book leaving Pierre as main heir.

The Bolkonskys are an old established wealthy family based with a head of the family who's a complete and total control freak. The old prince (as he's known) served as a general under Catherine the Great in earlier wars. His son Andrei (the superb Alan Dobie in the BBC version) I would say is the other main character, a close friend of Pierre, who serves with the Russian army before being fatally wounded at Borodino

The Rostovs have many estates, but never enough cash - they are almost the opposite of the Bezukhov's as they're pretty close, but the father is not good with money and is losing it hand over fist...

The lesser families in terms of main story are the Kuragin family who have three children, all of questionable character and the Drubetskoy's who are an elderly mother and her only son, Boris one of the biggest social climbers you could ever not want to meet...

So that's it - it's point less me telling you what the story is because it so huge and rambling I'd be writing a post almost as long as War and Peace, but suffice to say my favourite parts of the book are the military elements (there's a lot of civilian story too, mostly about the loves and losses of the younger female members of the families) Tolstoy is very good on battles, his depiction of Borodino was superb, and his depiction of the disintegration of the French army shortly after their decision to retreat is nothing short of brilliant...  he has some excellent little inserted stories about partisans, and Cossacks, raiding the retreating army..  superb....  and despite the fact it was written in 1869 I kept thinking it was an allegory for the later Winter War of WWII...

Anything I didn't like??  Well to be honest, the second half of the book (roughly) has far more of Tolstoy's philosophical meanderings - I don't doubt they are illuminating , but for me they got in the way of the story to a certain extent - when you're half way through a Cossack raid on a French supply train, you don't then want a chapter and a half on why Tolstoy thought the French had fallen to this level of deterioration (much as what he said had conviction)

Likewise I found the two epilogues hard work, the first one was OK as it dealt to a certain extent with the lives of the Bolksonsky's, Rostov's and Bezukhov's after the war but the second epilogue is a huge philosophical meander in the meanings of power, how people get it, how it is used, and how it was that one man could persuade 600,000 men to invade Russia.

So enough's enough - Steve the Wargamer rates this edition as 7 out of 10, you can get abridged versions that edit/remove the philosophical/history elements - but then you'd not be reading the book Tolstoy wrote.... recommended if only you read it once!

Skirmish at Signal Tower Hill - Game

So to continue from the previous post herewith...

The Game:

A fairly short game - I think we worked out afterwards it was about a dozen moves....

Either way, while the Confederate signal corps observe proceedings (picture following), Jackson's Brigade lurch forward in reaction to the approach of the Union brigade opposite...  my intent is to deploy as a blocking force no further forward than the edge of that ploughed field but in line abreast..

...like follows - artillery has also deployed....

On the other flank (picture below) however, we had both seemingly come to the same conclusion and were using it as our flanking edge...  the cornfield and farm would see the site of some serious fighting...

I shifted one of the regiments in Garnett's (picture below) to cover the approaches to the farm as DG clearly had the intention of seizing it so as to cover his flank march... 

About move 5or 6 (picture below) and the battle lines are drawing close - musketry ranges are fairly long but initial volleys have been exchanged - the artillery has been banging away at each other fairly ineffectively for some time, but mine clearly now has a tempting target to its front..

Three or four moves later (picture below) and we switch back to the left flank where DG can be seen manoeuvring the remains of his sorry band of Zouaves.. his Brigade as a whole however had done well and as you can see the other regiments remain at near or full strength.. mine however, are nearing end - the blue pin signifies half strength so in Rank and File rules these troops remain shaken - they can't recover, only remain the same or get worse...  we used the small dice to track hits as these are carried over move to move (unlike Blitzkrieg Commander where they are removed at the end of the turn) - 3 hits and a base is removed...

On the right it's far more evenly balanced (picture below) but this isn't the strategically important flank..  in the cornfield Wheat's Tigers unleash the rebel yell (and their fury) on the Union regiment to their front... interestingly (or not!) there's no bonuses for charging which I found a little strange - charging unit can't fire but gets no equivalent of the Fire and Fury "cold steel" bonus.....  

Left flank a couple of moves later (picture below) and my force has all but disappeared leaving the objective wide open unless I can get units from my right flank disengaged to protect it..

....which wasn't going to happen in time (picture below) - the Zouaves have seen off that Union regiment, but not enough for them to be able to turn their back on the remaining unit which hovers just out of range - they're too far away from the signal tower anyway... 

I do like this picture....

....and that's where we (or rather I) called it... it was getting late, and it was clear that I couldn't win the game even though it wasn't completely over... so a Union victory to DG.

Post Match Analysis:

• Casualties... first the Union:



First Brigade: Colonel Nathan Kimball 39th Illinois - 5 bases lost 2 8th Ohio - 5 bases lost 3 67th Ohio - 5 bases lost 2

Second Brigade: Colonel Jeremiah C. Sullivan 84th Pennsylvania - 5 bases 14th Indiana - 4 bases lost 2 5th New York Volunteer Infantry "Duryée's Zouaves" - 5 bases lost 3

Artillery: Battery L, 1st Ohio - 12pdr Napoleon


Next the Confederates..:



Garnett's Brigade 2nd Virginia - 4 bases routed from the field 27th Virginia - 4 bases routed from the field 33rd Virginia - 5 bases lost 2

Jackson's Brigade The First Louisiana Special Battalion: Wheat's Tigers - 5 bases lost 1 4th Virginia - 5 bases lost 2 5th Virginia - 5 bases lost 1

Artillery: Carpenters Virginia Battery - 12pdr Napoleon Destroyed


So 15 bases lost v's 12 - DG comprehensively won the signal tower flank, I had him running on the other one.. where it didn't matter....

• The rules played very well - DG had put together a summary sheet that was extremely useful...  I had some concerns about the numbers of modifiers early on, but can confidently say that after 3 moves it was mostly from memory... what did I like??


1. Much simpler firing mechanisms (throw x D6's per base - you score a hit on a modified 4+, a base is removed for every 3 hits), 
2. Melee also worked well (similar mechanisms). 
3. Movement is fairly business as usual but manoeuvring rules were much simpler
4. You roll each turn for initiative (winner decides whether they want to move first or last), then after that firing/melee is simultaneous..
5. Morale is very interesting - the 50% rule in particular I like very much - once a unit gets down to half strength their morale can never recover - the best they can expect to do is stay at the same level which at least allows them to shoot or melee at a much reduced effect - very clever... there are also some interesting army level morale break points that I'

All in all - roll on the next game!

Skirmish at Signal Tower Hill - Set Up

....so after the furore that was Salute has settled, finally some time to sit down and organise the pictures and accompanying account of the game that DG and I managed to get in that same weekend.. I can only apologise to DG for how long this has taken - been busy!

Having just completed a couple of regiments for the American Civil War Project (more details here [clicky] and here [clicky]) and having unfinished business with regard to the rules for this period we decided that this visits game would be WWII....no, ACW of course...

DG and I have tried a number of sets of rules for this period (they're documented in the ACW Project page [clicky]) but the latest set, "Regimental Fire and Fury", which had shown such promise, finally paled for me during the final game of our postal campaign (which I still need to write up)...  too many things to remember, too many variations, too many options, too restrictive in manoeuvrability (which may be historically accurate, but can be a little tedious in a game - there is a fine balance and they came down on the failed side for me though I appreciate this is very much a personal opinion).

Either way, DG had been playing "Rank and File" with his local club  and based on his recommendation we decided I should also give it a go... (NB. there are a couple of excellent posts by this chap to give you a flavour of the mechanisms, he posted these somewhat handily just before the game and I found them very useful (introduction [clicky] and play test [clicky]) An interesting aside, these rules are by Crusader who also wrote "Rate of Fire", the WWII skirmish set I use (and like)...

So, I decided on an encounter game given that DG and I were play testing  the rules - two infantry forces of six regiments and a piece of artillery each; I left the cavalry out for this first game. The infantry was arranged in two brigades  with relevant command (and at this point I realised I needed more command hence the purchase at Salute ) and once again for ease & simplicity were all classed as regulars with rifled muskets...

Union OOB:

First Brigade: Colonel Nathan Kimball 39th Illinois - 5 bases 8th Ohio - 5 bases 67th Ohio - 5 bases

Second Brigade: Colonel Jeremiah C. Sullivan 84th Pennsylvania - 5 bases 14th Indiana - 4 bases 5th New York Volunteer Infantry "Duryée's Zouaves" - 5 bases

Artillery: Battery L, 1st Ohio - 12pdr Napoleon

Confederate OOB:

Garnett's Brigade 2nd Virginia - 4 bases 27th Virginia - 4 bases 33rd Virginia - 5 bases

Jackson's Brigade The First Louisiana Special Battalion: Wheat's Tigers - 5 bases 4th Virginia - 5 bases 5th Virginia - 5 bases

Artillery: Carpenters Virginia Battery - 12pdr Napoleon

We played on the 6' x 4' version of my table, across the wide sides, so with 20mm figures the forces filled the table nicely while still allowing for a little flank marching if the need overcame us... a reminder of the table is as follows...


 
Deployment:

Having in the picture above the Confederates deployed on the left, Union on the right - the signal tower was the Union objective.

I played Confederates and deployed in an unsurprising manner given the objective and the terrain - the only significant difference was to keep one regiment back on each flank as it would allow me to deploy them left or right depending on what DG did. I kept my stronger brigade  (Jackson's) on the right close to the signal tower as I assumed that would be where most of DG's force would be concentrated..

In the picture above; Confederate deployment looking right flank to left.... Garnett's brigade in the foreground, Jackson's in the distance, artillery in the centre..

Union Deployment pretty much matched the Confederate one... DG is caught mid deployment... he put the 1st Brigade on his left, 2nd (with the Zouaves) on the right - his artillery was also with this brigade..

Stay tuned for the game report...

Salute 2013 - part 2 - a review...

...and so to part two....

This was one of the best Salutes in some time for good looking games (in my opinion)

In third place then was this game by Battlefront Miniatures and run by Barry Hilton - "The Battle of Little Big Top"  using his own soon to be released ACW rules "Rally to the Colours".

This won "Best Sponsored Trader Game"and given it was up against some pretty games elsewhere, this was a good result...

...that hill was quite steep..  superb terrain...

In second place...  Nantwich Gamers presented "When Chaos Reigns"  a 28mm WWII game - this won the "Salute Shield Best of Show Game" and quite deservedly!

...another game where the level of detail was simply stunning..

Look at the stowage on those Sherman's... definitely on campaign..

Puma's - one of my favourites.. 

The windmill particularly appealed..  it didn't move or light up, just solid modelling, and a good terrain to support it..

Look at that terrace...  and all in 28mm...!

...and so finally, we come to first place...  drum roll etc.

I'm a black powder gamer so for me it was a complete and utter no brainer, I saw the game and before I'd seen anything else I already knew it was the best game....  so, this is "Waterloo 1815" presented by the Essex Gamesters - this won "Salute Challenger Second Overall" losing out to the game above...

..the big view looking along the British line from right to left flank...  French grand battery to the right of the picture..

Some detail - tourists and sightseers...

Hougemont..

La Haye Saint in the distance...

British Heavy's...

French Heavy's...  no more successful this time than last time...

Close up of La Haye Saint..

....and to complete the multi format presentation that is this blog...  herewith a brief vid to show the sheer scale and size of the thing...

...and that's it....  all I can say is roll on next year!

Salute 2013.. a review..

My feet have just about recovered....  albeit it's three days later... 

Another superb show and I can only echo my fellow bloggeratti when I say that the Warlords [clicky] have again triumphed - every year this show seems to get better and better, and  it now fills the available space very nicely, but without it feeling claustrophobic - it's one of those things where those high ceilings work well...

Downsides?? Nothing major... I like the venue, I like the (geographic) location, I bring my own food  ()...  it does seem to me that over the years that the percentage difference between historical and fantasy is gradually going more and more fantasy, but it's such huge show there's still plenty of historical flavour,and while it may not be my cup of tea some of the fantasy based games are still fascinating...  happily the instance of historical re-enactors was lower this year as well...I don't mind the Star Wars guys, but why are the historical dudes always on the "large" side (and therefore totally a-historical)?

Another low key show on the purchasing front - Sean at Newline Designs [clicky] was doing a Salute sale (24 figure unit packs at 30% off), so I took the opportunity to re-stock my 20mm ACW painting piles with a pre-order of 3 packs of various combinations of marching infantry...   I wanted to get some rifled artillery as well but Sean doesn't have them (yet!), so I managed to get some Parrots from the SHQ [clicky] stand, along with some mounted command. I also bought myself a small razor saw to add to the modelling tool box, and that was it...   I find increasingly these days that the shows for me are a way of seeing things in the flesh that I then subsequently order via the web - the size of the ranges that manufacturers carry these days makes it impossible for them to bring everything and although I'm interested most of the new ranges are plastic (blechhhh....) or 28mm (not my scale) ...

...and so on to the games.....  very difficult this year for me to work out the winning order....  first place was easy (and having seen a few of the blogs I'm not alone in my choice), but deciding the places of those games lower down the order was very difficult simply because they were so good... as usual, and in my own curmudgeonly way they are the games that appealed to me....  the chances are if it involved fantasy, hexes, 6mm, or a period that didn't tickle my fancy (Dark Ages or Ancients unfortunately fall into this category) that's why they don't appear...  

I took a lot of pictures but as I dislike huge picture filled posts I may split this over a few parts....either way here goes....  drum roll....   and in seventh place (not "last") we have this little American Civil war set-to which appealed to me greatly, not the least because the guys were having a whale of a time playing it, and the umpire was throwing those cotton wool balls around the place like they were going out of fashion...now I think this was the Newbury  & Reading guys doing "Chancellorsville  1863 - The Trap is Sprung" but my notes are unclear, so if it's not, let me know...  if it is, then I think this will feature in a future edition of Miniature Wargames...

"Look Dad, zouaves!"

The lead was certainly flying if the cotton wool balls are anything to go by!

In 6th place - and clear evidence that if the game appeals enough to me - and the terrain for this game was simply superb - then even Ancients stand a chance of getting into my top 10...   so in 6th place we have this oriental siege game put on by Oshiro Model Terrain - "Assault on Aki Kamei-jo"

I've mentioned the Oshiro guys before as one of their games was a favourite last year...  they specialise in Japanese/Samurai era and it shows....  this depicted what they saw as a typical Samurai period siege..

In 5th place,"Stalingrad 1942, The Rat War" from Arbuthnot's Terra Firma League of Gentlemen, the guy running this had just been presented with the Best Scenery award, and was absolutely gob smacked Very nice guy, totally overwhelmed, but stunning scenery...

The whole project started when he bought the two buildings below at last years show, and then wondered what he would do with them!

All the boards are interchangeable,and can be turned by 90 or 180 degees so that an infinite number of alternatives tables can be made...

In fourth place, and it's getting really difficult tosperate them now! This was "To Berlin" from the Chemins De Feu Club and it was stunning..  no other word for it.... the level of detail was amazing..

Armoured train - click - one vote straight away!

Look at the detail inside the buildings..  how much work has gone into this??

You just know that things are not going to go well for that Panther!

"Knock, knock, Avon calling..."

Brilliant...  stay with me for the top 3 in part 2...